Ex-Premier League star draws parallels between Marcus Rashford and Aston Villa switch: Strained relationship with manager could prevent Manchester United return

The 27-year-old player made a loan move to Villa Park for the remainder of the season, following a decline in playing time under the new Manchester United manager, Ruben Amorim.

The Portuguese manager seemed to hint in the media that he hadn’t been entirely happy with Rashford’s training, and the loan deal gives Villa the option to make the move permanent in the summer for £40m.

Why a loan can work

Rashford is not the first player in history to be loaned out after not seeing eye to eye with a manager, and he won’t be the last.

Jermaine Pennant also went through a similar situation during his time at Real Zaragoza, and believes a loan switch did him the world of good.

“When I was in Spain, I wasn’t seeing eye to eye with the manager, there was the language barrier and he wasn’t playing me, so I went on loan to Stoke,” Pennant told FFT.

“I had a great six months at Stoke and I signed permanently, so it does work. As footballers, all we want to do is play football. That is it.”

Get FourFourTwo Newsletter

The best features, fun and footballing quizzes, straight to your inbox every week.

Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

Pennant thinks Rashford’s loan move could work out, too. “You just want to get out and play,” he said.

“I think this could be a fantastic move for him. Aston Villa is a good club in a great position, in the Champions League, fighting for fourth, and they’ve just sold Jhon Duran, so I think this could be a moment where it reignites his career.

“When you’re not seeing eye to eye with a manager, sometimes it’s hard to be in that atmosphere and that vicinity, and get the best out of yourself. It can hinder your performances and your training, because there’s that animosity to one another.

“Now he’s got a blank sheet, he can train hard and show what Marcus Rashford can actually do, because there is a great player inside there somewhere.”

The point of no return

Whatever happens for Rashford at Aston Villa, Pennant doesn’t envisage him returning to Old Trafford.

“I don’t think we’ll see Marcus Rashford at Manchester United again,” the 42-year-old said, speaking in association with ​​NewBettingSites.uk.

“He may go back there, but I think he’ll get sold. I think that relationship now has come to an end, with the fans, with the club, with the manager, with the board.

“Too much has gone on behind the scenes now – even if he lights it up at Aston Villa, I just think they’re both going to part ways.

“He’s playing for himself, he’s playing for his pride, if he wants a move to a decent club, this is the time and place to showcase what he can do.

“The next chapter in his career is all on him. He’s got the place to showcase that now, he’s got to take that opportunity."